Old Fashioned Custard Pie A traditional egg, milk, and sugar based pie. A Than Saturday, July 20, 2019 Edit Old Fashioned Custard Pie A traditional egg, milk, and sugar based pie. A Thanksgiving dessert. Read Ingredients and Instructions Click Here Share this post Related PostsGorditasEaster Sugar CookiesVanilla Cardamom Shortbread Snowflake Sandwich Cookies with Espresso Buttercream FillingMexican Tater Tot Casserole – Tots never go out of style on the dinner tableCrispy Black Bean Tacos with Avocado-Lime SauceRaspberry Pretzel SaladHow to Make Perfect, No-Fail CaulitatoesEasy Roasted Garlic Butter Shrimp